Booklist Review, Starred Review
Hand, Elizabeth. Generation
Loss. Apr. 2007. 296p. Small Beer, $24.95 (1-931520-31-6).
Hand, mainly known for sf/fantasy stories, veers
off in a new and exciting direction, drawing on but going well beyond
the crime genre. Three decades ago, Cassandra Neary was an avant-garde
photographer whose book, Dead Girls, was published to acclaim. But
her hard-driving lifestyle, in concert with the rapid collapse of
the counterculture, led to a downward spiral. Salvation appears
in the form of an editor who offers her the chance to interview
a reclusive photographer, Aphrodite Kamestos. But when Cass arrives
at the photographer’s private island, she finds that Kamestos had
no idea she was coming. Rather than turn around and go home, Cass
decides to use the opportunity to find out what she can about Kamestos,
uncovering a few shocking secrets and one old mystery in the process.
Hand combines elements of the traditional amateur-sleuth mystery
with a visceral story of personal redemption, and her pulsating
prose smacks us in the face with frank, fascinating discussions
of sex and drugs and with staccato dialogue peppered with expletives.
The utterly compelling protagonist, whose self-loathing competes
with her hatred of life to see which can beat her into submission
first, wins us over almost in spite of herself. Brilliantly written
and completely original, Hand’s novel is an achievement with a capital
A.
—David Pitt
Entertainment Weekly Review
Generation Loss
Thirty years ago, Cassandra Neary's grim photos
of punks and corpses briefly made her the toast of the downtown
art scene. Now an alcoholic wage slave, Neary accepts a magazine
assignment to interview one of her reclusive photographer heroes
on a Maine island, where a rash of missing-teenager cases and an
off-kilter populace grab her attention. It takes time to warm to
the self-destructive, sour-tempered protagonist --she drives drunk,
pops Adderall and Percocet, and generally tries to not stick out
her neck. Luckily, Hand's terse but transporting prose keeps the
reader turning pages until Neary's gritty charm does, finally, shine
through.
--Sean Howe
Locus Review
Generation Loss review by Nick Gevers.
Elizabeth Hand, author of stylish, poetic, and
myth-saturated literary fantasies, has written a thriller about
a serial murderer, with only tangential supernatural elements: *Generation
Loss*. Certainly, when Cassandra Neary begins telling her life story,
one may expect it to develop into another of Hand's excellent analyses
of artistic obsession married to ghostly influence: Cass's early
years are studded with visions, premonitions, a sinister voice murmuring
her name (Shepard's Sadie started that way, and look what happened
to her!) But these episodes, swiftly narrated, are essentially aesthetic
and psychological background, explaining Cass's preoccupation with
death, her alienation from diurnal emotions, her preternatural understanding
of image and atmosphere. Cass becomes a professional photographer
in New York, and her destiny, however tied up with illusion and
delusion, lies in the secular world, and in the thriller domain
of Thomas Harris and his gory ilk. Still...
Cass originates in Kamensic, a village in New York State familiar
from *Black Light* and other of Hand's fantastic works. Perhaps
she carries thence some burden of transcendent enlightenment, informing
(for example) her instinctive recognition of damage in others, a
necessary prompt to get her camera ready to capture the essence
and outcome of that quality. Possibly Hand, always subtle, has penned
in *Generation Loss* a text subliminally supernatural. But that's
speculative. The thriller outline is clear. Cass, a disciple of
Diane Arbus and the punk movement, becomes briefly famous for her
photos of the dead and dying, the injured, the afflicted. She publishes
a well regarded book of these. But trends change, and she is relegated
to obscurity, her craft in collapse, her subsistence dependent on
work in a bookstore. She is promiscuous, drug-addled, emotionally
stunted. For decades she lives an empty half-life, careless of her
safety (she is raped in horrifying yet numbed circumstances) and
with few friends or lasting lovers (one, to make things worse, dies
on 9/11.) She is a Luddite in photographic terms, scorning the digital
technologies her peers employ. But in the midst of this stagnation,
she receives an intriguing offer.
The assignment is to visit and interview Aphrodite Kamestos, another
famous but washed-up photographer living on Paswegas, a small island
off the coast of Maine. Hesitant because the commission comes from
a dubious source, Cass nonetheless drives up to Maine, meeting several
interesting characters in and around the small community of Burnt
Harbor before venturing on to Paswegas. Cass gradually becomes conscious
of two disturbing facts: first, teenagers have a tendency to disappear
in this depressed area of Maine, some as runaways, but others less
easily explained; and second, Aphrodite stood once at the center
of a Sixties bohemian commune, relicts of which are still around,
aging, frustrated, and in one case murderous. If Cass is ever to
come to terms with her own damaged and malicious self, ever resurrect
her own photographic genius, she will have to solve and resolve
these and associated perplexities. "Generation loss" assumes at
least three crucial meanings—the fading or diminished quality of
photos as they are reproduced over and over (time and declining
integrity and definition, in Cass as in others); the loss of the
younger generation of local inhabitants (matching Cass's own loss
of self when young); and the decay of creative power in the aesthetes
lingering from Aphrodite's commune (they were artists and poets
too; will Cass share the dying of their fires?) Grappling with these
tendencies and meanings, Cass in a sense murders someone herself,
but her sin is as nothing compared with that of the serial killer
at work nearby, a monster practicing bloody and arcane rites in
attempted re-ignition of his own departing inspiration. Genre thriller
expectations are abundantly sated, and yet Hand's complex themes
are triumphantly catalyzed and elaborated thereby, making for that
rare thing: a thriller that means something. This one means a lot…
So *Generation Loss* is a fine "associational" book: something
of a departure for the author, but fully as elegant and significant
as her overtly fantastic works. There is grave beauty here, and
great thematic power.
Journal Sentinel Review
A Click in Time
GENERATION LOSS, By Elizabeth Hand, Small Beer Press 265 pages $24.
"Generation Loss" by Elizabeth Hand has been rightly compared with
the sort of crime fiction turned out by the late, great Patricia
Highsmith. Of course, Hand's sensibilities are much more in tune
with the time, making it an easy read.
Having had her time in the sun - taking photographs of once-famous
Punk Rockers in the 1970s - Cass Neary is a has-been who chomps
at the bit when an assignment to photograph Aphrodite Kamestos,
one of the '60s great photographer/artists, lands in her lap.
Of course, Cass discovers that her idol isn't nearly as noble as
the art she created. What's more, the reader discovers that amorality
(and morality, for that matter) is all in the eye of the beholder.
Cass' actions after meeting Aphrodite - and checking out a commune
she created - led to the discovery of who might be behind a decades-old
murder mystery. And judging by the fresh bodies, it's a mystery
that could be ongoing.
Hand ("Mortal Love," "Black Light") expertly ratchets up the suspense
until it's at the level of a high-pitched scream near novel's end.
And her characters are expertly drawn.
- Dorman Shindler, Special to the Journal Sentinel
Publishers Weekly Review
Generation Loss, Hand, Elizabeth (Author), ISBN: 1931520216 Small Beer Press, Published 2007-04, Hardcover, $24.00 (320p), Fiction | Mystery & Detective - General- Reviewed 2007-02-19 -PW
Hand (Mortal Love ) explores the narrow boundary between artistic
genius and madness in this gritty, profoundly unsettling literary
thriller. Cass "Scary" Neary, a self-destructive photographer, enjoyed
her 15 minutes of fame snapping shots of the punk scene's most squalid
moments. Now forgotten and aging gracelessly, Cass gets a shot at
rehabilitation when a friend assigns her to interview Aphrodite
Kamestos, a photographer from the fringe of the '60s counterculture,
whose morbid vision influenced Cass herself. On remote Paswegas
Island off the coast of Maine, Cass finds a dissipated and surly
Aphrodite who sees in Cass the darkest aspects of herself. Worse,
Cass discovers that a remnant of a commune Aphrodite helped found
has taken her bleak aesthetic to the next level in an effort to
penetrate mysteries of life and death. Cass is a complex and thoroughly
believable character who behaves selfishly-sometimes despicably-yet
still compels reader sympathy. The novel's final chapters, in which
Cass confronts a horrifying embodiment of the extremes to which
her own artistic inclinations could lead, are a terror tour-de-force
that testify to the power of great fiction to disturb and provoke.(Apr.)
Copyright © 1997-2005 Reed Business Information, a division
of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Fantasy Magazine Review 2006
SAFFRON AND BRIMSTONE
This collection consists of both the type of fine
stories expected from Elizabeth Hand and stories showing a fascinating
new direction. A "typical" Hand story is novella length, written
in rich language, and full of human details of daily life that allow
an intimate knowledge of characters. These damaged beings are often
overtaken by darkness, but that doesn't mean death, loss, and loneliness
ultimately triumph. The fantastic provides the possibility that
darkness can be illumined and reality realigned by magic. When Hand
does allow doom, it usually serves a higher justice as in the horrific
"Cleopatra Brimstone", in which an American student lepidopterist
recovering from rape winds up in London as an uncanny serial killer.
Faith triumphs in "Pavane for a Prince of the Air" when a woman
who has faith in nothing and a modern tribe of aging ex-hippies
who believe in just about anything deal with the difficult death
of a once-vibrant friend. The narrator's world in "The Least Trumps"
has become confined almost completely to an island within an island,
but she discovers the world need not necessarily remain mundane.
(These first three stories were collected in the limited edition
Bibliomancy [PS Publishing, 2003], but the earlier collection's
excellent "Chip Crockett's Christmas Carol" is inexplicably missing
here.) The narrator of "Wonderwall" learns there are other ways
to gouge a hole in the wall of reality than self-destructive hedonism.
Grouped as "The Lost Domain", the four final stories all center
on love and memory. But memory here is mutable and love vacillates
or is illicit. It abides, but is transitory. Lovers meet but cannot
share a life. An immortal learns to deal with inevitable loss in
the entrancingly mythic "Calypso in Berlin". "Echo" is the eternally
lonely story of a woman who waits. In "Kronia" love may not even
have existed. The scintillating "The Saffron Gathers", original
to the collection, ends the book on a note of uncertainty and disaster.
This quartet is shorter, more sparsely written, less fantastic,
than "old" Hand; the stories also seem more personally relevant.
The entire collection further confirms Hand as an author of extraordinary
vision who is unafraid to dream in new directions.
Library Journal, starred review
SAFFRON & BRIMSTONE
Hand, Elizabeth. Saffron and Brimstone: Strange Stories. Milwaulkie Pr:. Nov. 2006. c.275p. ISBN 1-59582-096-5 [ISBN 978-1-59582-096-9]. pap. $14.95. F
Lovely and unsettling, these eight stories by
Hand (Maze of Deception) give a sensual and apocalyptic perspective
on modern society, with art, death, and sex all swirled together.
Lines between human and animal, past and future, and imagination
and action become blurred, as in "Cleopatra Brimstone," in which
a young entomologist finds that she may have some traits in common
with her research subjects, or as in "The Least Trumps," in which
a tattoo artist discovers a mysterious deck of tarot cards that
may be able to alter reality. The stories are beautifully crafted
but are not simply an exercise in style—they reveal deeper themes
and connections, echoing one another in subtle ways that enhance
the collection as a whole. Hand is often classed as a fantasy writer,
but this book also belongs in literary fiction collections. Highly
recommended for larger libraries.
[This is an expansion of the limited U.K. release
Bibliomancy, which won the World Fantasy Award in 2005.—Ed.]—Jenne
Bergstrom, San Diego Cty. Lib
Locus Review
SAFFRON & BRIMSTONE REVIEW, 2006
Elizabeth Hand seems to have
an issue with walls. A wall in a Manhattan loft turns into an immense
slab of rock in 1999’s Black Light; a wall in a hidden London lane
in 2004’s Mortal Love reveals to the poet Swinburne a seductive
green world; the dissolute narrator of 2004’s “Wonderwall”—one of
eight stories in her new collection Saffron and Brimstone—obsesses
over how to “tear through the wall that separated me from that other
world, the real world, the one I glimpsed in books and music, the
world I wanted to claim for myself.” In fact, “Wonderwall”, which
may turn out to be one of the iconic works in Hand’s oeuvre, is
full of walls, but none of them are quite the happy knotholes-to-faerie
that fantasy tradition might lead us to expect; in fact the first
time a wall disappears on the narrator all it reveals to her is
the overcrowded men’s room in tough gay disco in D.C. More to the
point, perhaps, is the wall of her dorm room, where she paints in
foot-high letters a line from Rimbaud, which she learns decades
later would “bleed through each successive layer of new paint”,
like a dream constantly trying to reassert itself. In “The Saffron
Gatherers”, one of a new suite of stories included in the volume,
a real Minoan fresco from the island of Santorini serves as another
window into a lost world, preserved almost entirely through its
art (Santorini was the site of perhaps the worst volcanic eruption
on record); by the end of the story we’re left wondering what images
might preserve our own civilization. In other words, walls may be
a key metaphor for the sense of immanence that pervades Hand’s work,
but it’s a complex metaphor: they can both separate us from the
world of art and be art, and what they reveal when they disappear
may be a transcendent landscape or a bunch of guys at a urinal.
Saffron and Brimstone includes
three of the four stories from Hands World Fantasy Award-winning
collection Bibliomancy, published in a small edition by PS in 2003,
omitting Chip Crocketts Christmas Carol (now available
as a chapbook from Beccon Press in England) and adding Wonderwall
and the new story suite The Lost Domain, which includes
four variations on themes of muses and nymphs: Kronia,
Calypso in Berlin, Echo, and The Saffron
Gatherers. Of the three stories from that earlier collection,
the most famous is Cleopatra Brimstone, which seems
on its way to becoming a kind of classic of the sort of seriously
literary horror which has emerged increasingly in the last few years.
Concerning a young student entomologist who is brutally raped and
flees to London, where she alternates her days as a volunteer in
the insect collection of the London Zoo with an ominous alter ego
haunting the clubs of Camden Town under the name Cleopatra Brimstone
(from the butterfly species), the story elegantly balances a kind
of supernatural revenge fantasy with an acute awareness of the real
horrors of womens lives. As with all her fiction, the sense
of place is palpable, though its interesting, given the autobiographical
bits that show up here, that its one of only two stories not
to use a first-person narrator. Pavane for a Prince of the
Air, a heartbreaking fictionalized account of a friends
death from cancer surrounded by aging flower children and mystics,
becomes also a meditation on the usefulness and futility of belief.
In The Least Trumps, the emotionally damaged daughter
of a famous childrens book writer sets herself up as a tattoo
artist in her mothers remote island cottage in Maine. At a
rummage sale she comes across a strange deck of mostly blank Tarot
cards which may have belonged to another famous author whose young
adult novels had guided the narrator through her adolescence, and
whose final unfinished novel had made cryptic references to the
least trumps. At the end, when the narrator tentatively achieves
an emotional connection with an old friend, theres a hint
(well, more than a hint) of the John Crowley idea of immanent secret
histories (and of course its from Crowleys Little, Big
that the idea of the least trumps is borrowed in the first place).
This leaves us with the remarkable
variations on a theme that make up The Lost Domain,
a notion borrowed from the 1913 Alain-Fournier novel (also translated
as The Wanderer) by way of John Fowles, whose fascination with the
idea of a hidden realm of imagination was detailed by Hand in a
revealing essay she wrote for The Journal of the Fantastic in the
Arts in 1994 (the same essay in which she noted the poet Laura Ridings
description of this idea as the false wall). Representing
an adventurous new direction in Hands writing, these four
pieces range freely from fantasy to SF to postmodern narrative fragmentation;
the brief opening overture, Kronia, explores a muse-like
relationship through isolated, sometimes contradictory memories,
at the center of which is the fall of the towers on 9/11. The more
fully plotted Calypso in Berlin transforms Odysseuss
sea-nymph into a New England painter living in Berlin who entraps
her favorite subject both literallyin a very creepy way--and
through her art. Both Echo and The Saffron Gatherers
move toward apocalyptic SF, the former story an aching parable of
loneliness in a dying worldagain told from the point of view
of an isolated island in Mainewhich casts the muse relationship
in a variation of the myth of Echo and Narcissus, the latter concerning
a science fiction novelist in Maine planning to move to the west
coast where her lover has relocated. Hes sent her a book on
the Thera frescoes from Santorini, which she once visited and which
are practically the only evidence of the daily life of a destroyed
civilization. But as her plane takes off from San Francisco, she
witnesses another huge natural catastrophe, another world lost.
The world may not be kind to muses in Hands beautifully orchestrated
tales, but its a world whose gorgeous fragility, like the
pistils of those tulips that are gathered for saffron, positively
glows in these radiant tales.
SFX Review
GLIMMERING, by John Courtney Grimwood
A novel of the coming millennium, announces the
cover. It isn't. At least it isn't a novel about our coming millennium,
though the references are current (hip New York shops, britpop,
retro Lou Reed, cable TV)
What this is though, is a very serious book. You
know it's serious because Elizabeth Hand keeps quoting TS Eliot.
And then there are the acknowledgements which credit Italian philosopher/novelist
Italo Calvino, not to mention dead rock-dude Kurt Kobain and microbiologist
Lynn Margulis. (There's also an interesting credit to SF authority
John Clude for showing her 'true north', mmm.)
Glimmering is what you'd get if you asked classic
US novelist Henry James to write Neuromancer but take in Nostradamus
and Japanese war atrocities, a clash of style against content that
occasionally clambers up towards sheer genius only to fall flat
on its face.
The basic plot is simple. Take rich, literate
HIV+ Jack and white trash Christian rock star Trip Marlow and make
circumstance inexorably bring the two together, while US society
collapses around them and Jack's old lover, the death artist and
mephistopheles-character Leonard tours the world recording its end.
The apparent complexity comes from that old (but
good) trick of adding depth by making sure events conflict. So that
two incidents are described as happening but the reader knows -
perfectly well - that one of them can't have done.
Depending on how you look at it, this book is
either three years or thirty years out of date. Thirty years too
late, because John Fowles did the complex, lets-not-make-sense routine
in the Magus - with which this book has startling (but probably
absolutely accidental) stylistic similarities. And three years too
late, at least as elegiac cyberpunk because the Millennium is currently
old hat.
We're not in 1998 yet close enough to be laying
in booze for the parties and we've already digested and discarded
the magazine articles about millennial fever, weird cults and crystal
gazing.
The whole back plot also gives problems, since
the whole novel turns on a new fuel being invented in 1996 and gutting
out the ozone layer a year later, leading to the destruction of
effective communications, the Glimmering. Even starting out in 1987
there's not enough time between 87 and 99 for all the new technology
to be realised.
Bits of this book are beautifully written. There's
a density of information that isn't about info-dumping but just
describing places and situations down the last intricate detail.
From the dense flowers that recur as a motif throughout the book;
to the Mongolian corporation that rules Wall Street and it elegant
metal covered, talking brochures (kind of Java-rich Web-pages but
on paper); to the tender, doomed love affairs (the main characters
are either gay, HIV + or dysfunctional).
Beautifully styled, literary rather than literate,
this is the kind of SF novel that wins mainstream prizes. A Booker-contender
that is SF almost by accident... In fact, if you stripped away Glimmering's
often clumby overlay of technology what you have left is ghosts,
myth, big houses and damaged people. A perfect Henry James for the
next century.
Kirkus Review — starred review
MORTAL LOVE
In fantasist Hand's crowded seventh novel, the
collision of our known world with the lushly erotic, magic-inflected
one of "faerie" bedevils mortal protagonists. A perilously seductive
eternal feminine figure- variously, the Iseult of medieval legend,
or a kind of Lamia, or Undine- delights, entrances, and effectively
destroys the generations of men who fall under her spell. For example,
there's 19th-century American painter Radborne Comstock (obviously
modeled on N.C. Wyeth), who while studying in London accepts employment
at Sarsinoor, an asylum on the Cornish coast run by art collector
Thomas Learmont. Among Learmont's patients are "mad" painters Jacobus
Candell and (an incarnation of "The Woman" herself) beautiful Evienne
Upstone. Radborne's infatuation with the latter is recapitulated
by his grandson Valentine, a deranged and troubled painter whose
ghostly encounter with a naked woman in a painting colors his life
and work, inspiring a rich fantasy world reminiscent of the classic
Arthurian tales and their recurrence in the Welsh story cycle Mabinogion.
And, contemporary journalist Daniel Rowlands, while researching
a study of the romantic story of Tristan and Iseult, becomes smitten
with Larkin Meade, a former mental patient whose power over Daniel
leads him to the ruins of Sarsinoor, as Hand (Black Light, 1999,
etc.) deftly plaits her three narrative strands together for a smashing
denouement and finale. Mortal Love contains numerous echoes of A.S.
Byatt's Possession and Peter Straub's Ghost Story, but it's an original
work of considerable sensuous force-thanks to entertaining cameo
appearances by amusingly libidinous and hysterical poet A.C. Swinburne
and truculent historian-folklorist Lady Wilde (Oscar's mother),
as well as Hand's detailed mastery of the gorgeously overstuffed
milieu of the pre-Raphaelite artists, whose own tangled sexual history
helps to maintain this novel's engagingly humid temperature. Great
fun, in an impressive synthesis of bygone times and forgotten lore.
Agent: Martha Millard/Martha Millard Literary
Agency
People Review
MORTAL LOVE, August 2, 2004
SECTION: PICKS & PANS/BOOKS; Pg. 47
LENGTH: 183 words
HEADLINE: Mortal Love;
by Elizabeth Hand
Jim Baker
A literary page-turner, this deeply pleasurable
eighth novel by the author of the cult classic Waking the Moon is
composed of interwoven narratives about three men: Radborne, a poor
Edwardian painter; Valentine, his bipolar grandson; and Daniel,
a contemporary journalist who is writing a book about Tristan and
Iseult, the mythical couple destroyed by their own love. The men
share an obsession with the same woman--an immortal femme fatale
(is she a ghost? a demon? a goddess?) who both inspires and tries
to destroy them. (She's a muse for Radborne, a trigger for Valentine's
illness and a lover for Daniel.) Hand ambitiously (and deftly) explores
the complex connection between art and madness, sex and death, love
and mortality. Despite the divergent narrative strands and the absence
of anything resembling a traditional plot, Hand's lushly worded
tale is consistently gripping. It may not always make perfect sense,
but logic is beside the point: Like all great fantasy fiction, Love
inhabits a world between reason and insanity-- it's a delightful
waking dream.
[4 STARS]
Washington Post Review
Victorian Secrets, Reviewed by Lawrence Norfolk — Sunday June 27, 2004
MORTAL LOVE By Elizabeth Hand. Morrow. 364 pp. $24.95
We know the images created
by the pre-Raphaelite painters of Victorian England too well. Seen
through modern eyes, the ethereal femmes fatales beloved of Edward
Burne-Jones or Dante Gabriel Rossetti appear now as little better
than projected male fantasies, vacuous and sentimental, visual clichés
on a par with Canaletto's Venice.
But are we seeing the pictures
themselves, or only our reductive preconceptions of them? Elizabeth
Hand has reclaimed the ur-impulses of the pre-Raphaelites -- their
delight in arcane folklore, fascination with nature and openness
to supernatural experience -- and created a pre-Raphaelite work
of her own. Mortal Love is at once a painting in prose, an investigation
into artistic obsession and a re-evaluation. We may see the strange,
attenuated women of pre-Raphaelite art rather differently after
reading Mortal Love. And, if the book's strange tale is to be believed,
they may see us differently, too.
The story begins in England
in the 1870s with that most unblushing and Victorian of opening
gambits: a letter. One director of an insane asylum, Dr. Hoffmann,
has written to another, Thomas Learmont, of the spontaneous combustion
of a young woman in his care. Hoffmann's name, one presumes, is
Hand's sly salute to the German folklorist; we never meet him in
person. Learmont will prove pivotal, but it is the dead woman who
will link the different times and locales in which Mortal Love is
set. Reduced to ashes before the novel begins, then reincarnated
as numerous women within it, she is the enigmatic object of quests
ranging from Victorian England to an island off the coast of Maine
in the 1980s, and from a remote coast in rural Cornwall to present-day
London.
Learmont is only the first
of a series of protagonists, all male, who encounter a strange and
alluring young woman, become drawn in by her, and then are mysteriously
damaged and discarded. She is pictured for us initially in the late
works of an eccentric and reclusive American painter, Radborne Comstock,
who seems to have been inspired by a meeting with her during a trip
to England in the 1880s. Comstock's obsessively detailed canvasses
show a fairy world that, a century later, enchants the painter's
young grandson, Valentine, who is compelled to create his own vision
of such a world and the mysterious woman at its center. Valentine
names the woman "Vernoraxia." In a hallucinatory scene,
she visits him in the guise of another woman, takes his virginity
and disappears, leaving Valentine in a state of catastrophic mental
breakdown.
Twenty years later, in present-day
London, a 44-year-old journalist named Daniel Rowlands has taken
a sabbatical to write a novel, or "an exploration of mythic
love," about Tristan and Iseult. Its working title: Mortal
Love. Soon Daniel's understanding of both those terms is being vigorously
redefined by the mysterious Larkin Meade, a possibly schizophrenic
young woman with a penchant for absinthe, offal and exotic underwear.
She introduces Daniel in turn to the wealthy Russell Learmont (descendant
of Thomas), who is bargaining to buy a late painting by Radborne
Comstock.
Mortal Love negotiates cleverly
between its 20th-century and Victorian time frames, embroiling us
in a rich stew of lost artworks, the folklore behind them and (merely
glimpsed) the reality behind that folklore. Those glimpses provide
the book's edgiest moments as Hand's carefully constructed realistic
settings cede to a vision of a green-glowing fairy world from which
the likes of Vernoraxia or Larkin might have credibly issued. Here
is the Victorian poet Swinburne, one of several real characters
reimagined by Hand, encountering that scene for the first time:
"Within a green world, prismatic things flickered and flew
and spun: rubescent, azure, luminous yellow, the pulsing indigo
of the heart's hidden valves. All were so brilliant he could see
nothing clearly. . . ." Alas, Swinburne's robust verbal reaction
to this vision cannot be quoted in a family newspaper, but the reader,
too, might utter the odd imprecation at such visual incoherence.
Such passages, however, are few and, like the occasional confusions
of geography and genealogy, hardly detract from the beguiling sense
of mystery that envelops the reader as Hand's disparate narratives
slowly braid themselves together.
Daniel's affair with Larkin
affords the reader an enjoyably twisty but dependable narrative
thread in the modern episodes. Comstock's sojourn in England does
the same for the Victorian era. With Comstock we are led through
a steaming, sodden London and introduced to its strangest denizens.
Hand's gift for deadpan comedy serves her well in larger-than-life
characterizations such as that of Swinburne and, most wonderfully,
the gargantuan mother of Oscar Wilde. Bolder still is her reclamation
of the hoary tropes of Victorian Gothic fiction: deformed servants,
decaying mansions, Learmont's insane asylum perched atop a remote,
crumbling cliff in Cornwall. The novel is stitched together with
enigmatic symbols and teasing coincidences.
All these conspire to give
Mortal Love a satisfying, story-rich texture. But Hand's use of
such traditional materials is also deceptive. The novel's presiding
artistic genius is neither Comstock nor Daniel Rowlands but Jacobus
Candell, a painter and inmate of Thomas Learmont's asylum. Candell
is modeled on the Victorian artist Richard Dadd, a murderer and
the creator of some of the strangest, most compelling and obsessive
images of the 19th century. Where could such inhuman creations have
come from? What lies behind the complex, even violent process that
we call artistic inspiration? That is the final mystery evoked in
Elizabeth Hand's ambitious and richly imagined novel. By tracing
the turbulence and reverberations of that process back to its source,
Mortal Love offers its readers the satisfactions of a detective
thriller. Here, however, the mystery goes deeper than murder. Nothing,
Hand convinces us, is quite as mysterious as art.
Lawrence Norfolk's latest
novel is "In the Shape of a Boar."
© 2004 The Washington
Post Company
PUBLISHERS WEEKLY
MORTAL LOVE, Elizabeth Hand. Morrow, $24.95 (320p) ISBN 0-06-105170-5
Hand (Black Light) explores the theme of artistic inspiration and
its dangerous devolvement into obsession and madness through three
interwoven narrative threads in this superb dark fantasy novel.
In late Victorian England, American painter Radborne Comstock makes
the acquaintance of Evienne Upstone, a model who's inspired members
of the pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood and driven painter Jacobus Candell
completely insane. More than half a century later, Radborne's grandson
Valentine ends up institutionalized after viewing intensely erotic
paintings grandpa produced under Evienne's spell. His experiences
echo those of Daniel Rowlands, an American writer in contemporary
London whose research into the legend of Tristan and Iseult brings
him into contact with Larkin Meade, a fey lover whose passion leaves
him physically and emotionally deranged. Subtle parallels and resonances
between the subplots suggest that Evienne and Larkin are, impossibly,
the same being: a force of nature incomprehensible to mortals, whom
countless doomed artists have translated imperfectly into aesthetic
ideals of beauty and love. Hand does a marvelous job of making the
ineffable tangible, lacing her tale with references to the work
of artists ranging from Algernon Swinburne to Kurt Cobain and capturing
the intense emotions of her characters in exquisitely sculpted prose.
With its authentic period detail and tantalizing spirit of mystery,
this timeless tale of desire and passion should reach many readers
beyond her usual fantasy base. Agent, Martha Millard. (On sale June
29)
Forecast: This one's a sure bet to garner World Fantasy and International
Horror Guild award nominations. Blurbs from Peter Straub and John
Crowley will help signal that this is Hand's breakout book.
Locus Review
BIBLIOMANCY, Elizabeth Hand (PS Publishing
1-902880-73-0 $50.00 290 pp. hc)
September 2003.
Order from www.pspublishing.co.uk
Bibliomancy -- a title as accurate as it is unusual
-- is Elizabeth Hand's first collection since 1998's Last Summer
at Mars Hill. The four long stories that comprise this new volume
all deal, in different ways, with the eruption of magic into the
everyday world. All four stories also share a sense of personal
urgency, as though their author had been driven to write them by
forces too compelling to ignore.
Leading off the collection is the International
Horror Guild Award winner, "Cleopatra Brimstone," which powerfully
evokes the surreal aftermath of a sexual assault. Hand's heroine,
Janie Kendall, is a brilliant, beautiful science student with a
preternatural affinity for butterflies. (At the age of thirteen,
her eyebrows sprout vestigial antennae, an unexpected offshoot of
puberty.) In her senior year at a select girls' college in Washington,
DC, Janie is raped while walking back to her college dormitory.
From this point forward, everything in her life changes.
Janie leaves school, moves to London to housesit
for a pair of family friends, and embarks on a double life. By day,
she works as a docent at the Regent's Park Zoo. By night, head shaved
and dressed to kill, she adopts the nom de guerre Cleopatra Brimstone
and prowls the nightspots of Camden High Street, bringing home a
host of willing victims for nights of sex, bondage, and miraculous
transformation. As the story moves toward its ironic denouement,
it evokes twisted echoes of John Fowles's The Collector and such
early Clive Barker tales as The Hellbound Heart and "Jacqueline
Ess: Her Will and Testament." In the end, though, "Cleopatra Brimstone"
is an original, deeply unsettling story about rage, revenge, and
sexual violence that illuminates a world in which predator and prey
play interchangeable roles.
Next up is another IHG award winner, "Pavane for
a Prince of the Air." The most strictly "realistic" of all the stories
gathered here, "Pavane" is an account -- rendered with documentary
precision -- of a man's slow, painful death, and of the effect that
death has on the surrounding community. As the story begins, Carrie,
the narrator, returns from a family visit to find an ominous message
on her answering machine: Cal -- artist, unreconstructed hippie,
and one of Carrie's oldest friends -- has just been diagnosed with
terminal cancer, and has only a short time to live.
The narrative that follows takes us deep into the
heart of a protracted death watch, with its vigils, its recurring
crises, and its endless stream of neo-pagan rituals. Cal, his wife,
Tina, and the majority of their circle are people "who believed
in everything. Fairies, elves, spirits of earth air water fire;
Tibetan gods, Minoan sea goddesses, totemic animals, reincarnation,
Iroquois spirits." Carrie, who witnesses all this, can't quite believe
in anything, and suffers as a result. Her unblinking account ranges
from the shock of first knowledge through Cal's death, burial, and
cremation, and into the weeks and months that follow, ending on
an ambiguous grace note that suggests -- but only suggests -- the
possibility of spiritual survival. The result is a lovely, lovingly
detailed memento mori written in luminous, effortlessly graceful
prose.
The centerpiece of Bibliomancy is the 40,000 word
short novel, Chip Crockett's Christmas Carol. As the title indicates,
Chip Crockett is yet another reimagining of A Christmas Carol. This
one, however, is smartly conceived and vigorously written, and successfully
transfers Dickens's vision to a very contemporary Washington, DC.
Hand's stand-in for Ebenezer Scrooge is Brendan Keegan, a failed
husband and indifferent lawyer who, like Dickens's original, has
lost his way. Brendan hates his work, is recently divorced, and
watches helplessly while his autistic son Peter retreats further
and further within himself. Brendan's malaise feeds an ongoing bitterness
that alienates friends, family, even strangers. The malaise itself
is the outward expression of a worldview in which "Marriages were
doomed. Mothers drowned their children. Your father developed Alzheimer's
disease and died without remembering your name . . . [He] now knew,
irrefutably, that the world had become the wasteland."
Like Dickens before her, Hand explores the nature
and dimensions of the wasteland in which Brendan has trapped himself,
and then proceeds to show him a way out. Help comes in the form
of the benign magic generated by the confluence of three very different
people: four-year-old Peter, a wonderfully characterized former
rock star known as Tony Maroni (read Joey Ramone), and the recently
deceased kids' show host, Chip Crockett. Chip, whose death is announced
in the opening page, is the ghost that haunts the narrative. Memories
of Chip's programs -- virtually none of which have been preserved
-- permeate the text, as Hand's cast -- notably Tony -- revel in
their memories of Chip and his comic creations: Ogden Orff, Captain
Dingbat, and the puppet known as Ooga Booga. These memories serve
as signposts of a better time, and help connect both Tony and Brendan
to the images of their own best selves. When rumors hint at the
imminent reappearance of a lost, legendary Christmas special --
Chip Crockett's Christmas Carol -- the story gains both momentum
and emotional depth, moving inexorably toward a credible resolution
filled with open, unabashed sentiment. Chip Crockett's Christmas
Carol has brains and humor, as well as heart, and deserves a place
on the select shelf of memorable holiday fables.
Bibliomancy ends with "The Least Trumps," which
appeared last year in The New Fabulists, a special issue of Conjunctions
magazine edited by Peter Straub. As admirers of John Crowley will
doubtless recognize, the Least Trumps is the name of the tarot deck
that plays a central role in Little, Big. Hand's novella is, in
fact, a conscious homage to Crowley, a reiteration of a classic
Crowleyan theme: There is more than one history of the world.
The heroine and narrator of "The Least Trumps"
is Ivy Tun, gay tattoo artist and daughter of iconic children's
author Blake E. Tun. In some respects, the story serves as a thematic
companion piece to Chip Crockett's Christmas Carol. Ivy, like Brendan
Keegan, has cut herself off from the outside world. She lives by
herself in a cottage called The Lonely House on an island within
an island off the coast of Maine. When forced to leave her solitary
home, she endures agoraphobic symptoms that include nausea and overwhelming
panic. These, in turn, are symptoms of a larger malaise, one that
Brendan would surely recognize. For Ivy, the real world can never
be as "welcoming" as the world of her favorite novels. "Who," she
asks herself, "would ever choose to bear the weight of this world?
Who would ever want to?"
Ivy finds help from an unexpected source: the eponymous
tarot deck purchased at a rummage sale, a deck once owned by Walter
Burden Fox, author of a series of fantasies she has loved since
childhood. Through a collaborative enterprise utilizing certain
images from the tarot deck and her own skills as a tattoo artist,
Ivy initiates a fundamental series of changes and comes to believe
that the world -- that history itself -- is astonishingly malleable.
Hand is among the most painterly of writers, and
her prose is filled with precise descriptions of arcane processes
-- tattooing, entomology, cremation, even bondage techniques --
and with luminous evocations of the physical world. Moving gracefully
from the gaudy surface of things to the tangled inner lives of its
all-too-human heroes, Bibliomancy offers the heartening sight of
a gifted writer really hitting her stride. Elizabeth Hand has always
been an ambitious, intelligent writer, but she seems to be working
at a higher level than ever before. It's therefore odd -- and a
bit depressing -- to note that Bibliomancy is only available in
a limited edition from a British specialty press. When a book this
good can't find a home with a major mainstream publisher, then the
industry itself is clearly in a state of deep, possibly dangerous,
decline.
HAND PUPPETS
From Washington Post Book World --
The cover image on Elizabeth Hand's newest book
-- a collection of four novellas from a U.K. publisher in a limited,
signed edition -- is a piece of High Victorian fantasy: A dreaming
woman sprawls languorously in bed while the phantoms of her mind
cavort in her chamber. As a metaphor for the contents of Bibliomancy
(PS Publishing, $50), the painting is perfect. The oneiric Hand
has indeed set loose a menagerie of specters within these pages.
The most terrifying of her conceptions comes first,
in "Cleopatra Brimstone." A young woman named Jane who is keen on
a career in science, specifically the taxonomy of butterflies, is
raped one night while in college. Afterward, in London to recuperate,
she takes on another identity. Calling herself "Cleopatra Brimstone"
after the common name of a butterfly, she becomes a merciless killer,
in a most uncanny fashion. "Pavane for a Prince of the Air" chronicles
how a colorful ex-hippie artist named Cal succumbs gradually to
brain cancer, and finds in the aftermath of his death some cause
for faith in the rightness of life. The centerpiece of the book,
in length, feeling and impact, is "Chip Crockett's Christmas Carol,"
a kissing cousin to Harlan Ellison's "Jeffty Is Five." This saga
of Scrooge-like lawyer Brendan Keegan, his autistic son Peter and
their free-spirited wastrel friend Tony Maroni assumes the dimensions
of a whole generation's biography. Finally, "The Least Trumps" focuses
on a tattoo artist named Ivy Tun, the daughter of a famous children's
book author. Almost a hermit, Ivy finds her world opening outward
when she purchases the odd Tarot deck of the title at a tag sale.
Repeated images of death and loss fill these tales,
and yet their overall effect is one of hope and uplift. Hand's close
attention to the cherished dailiness of life is matched only by
the subtlety of her fantastical conceits, producing a fiction that
acknowledges both mortality and the eternal. (In this she reminds
me not only of her idol, John Crowley, but also of Algernon Blackwood.)
Her abiding sense of humor -- seen most plainly in "Crockett" --
also rescues these dramas from any morbidness. Like Cal's friend
Carrie, helping wife Tina sift through Cal's ashes after cremation,
Hand is able to extract glinting bits of treasure from the shards
of despair. ?
Paul Di Filippo writes and reviews science
fiction.
|